That's When It Hurts the Most - Johnny Tillotson

(That's when it hurts the most)

I can't erase the mem'ry of the night you said goodbye

And when I pass you on the street I want to cry

But when I see you out with somebody new

That's when it hurts the most

It breaks my heart each time I read the note you left for me

And your picture makes me lonely as can be

But when I see you holding somebody new

That's when it hurts the most

Never never thought I'd miss you

But it's heartache heartbreak my whole life through

It makes me cry each time I think of how you once were mine

And I think about it darling all the time

But when I see you kissing somebody new

That's when it hurts the most

That's when it hurts the most